|<< WoR Ch. 88: The Man Who Owned The Winds / WoR Epilogue: Art and Expectation >>|
–From the Diagram, Floorboard 17: paragraph 2, every second letter starting with the second
Progression of the Chapter:
Adolin walks the halls of Urithiru pondering life; he encounters Sadeas, who intends to undermine Dalinar and take leadership from him; Adolin attacks and kills Sadeas; shocked, he drops Oathbringer out a window and removes the traces of his presence.
Dalinar ascends to the roof of the tower; he shouts at the Stormfather, who finally responds; their conversation is depressing; Dalinar demands to be made a Knight Radiant; defying the Stormfather's anger, he states the First Ideal of the Radiants, and the Second Ideal of the Bondsmiths; the Words are accepted, with conditions; the Stormfather denies having sent the morning's vision; Dalinar descends to meet Shallan and Kaladin; they identify their three Orders, and Renarin joins them as a fourth; Dalinar shares the bad news confirmed by the Stormfather; Kaladin prepares for a trip to Hearthstone while Renarin goes to requisition spheres for him; Dalinar and Shallan consider the situation and pledge to do what they can.
Quote of the Chapter:
Warm light bathed him. A deep, enveloping, piercing warmth. A warmth that soaked down deep through his skin, into his very self. He stared at that light, and was not blinded. The source was distant, but he knew it. Knew it well.
Then he awoke.
Dalinar doesn't know the significance of this vision, but it's profoundly beautiful. The first part of the vision places it in his childhood home, with his brother laughing in the next room and his just-outgrown collection of wooden swords carved like Shardblades still on display. It's fairly clear that this is not a memory - or at least, the part about the light isn't - but ... what is it?
(WoB says that the last chapter of The Stormlight Archive has already been seen in one of these two books. Does this seem a likely candidate? It may be a preview of Dalinar moving from the Cognitive Realm to Beyond. On the other hand, a reader has suggested the Fleet scene or Taln arriving at Kholinar.)
Development of the Chapter:
This is another chapter with several major events and a plethora of minor ones.
Aside from the content of the vision/dream Dalinar experienced, the timing is weird and the source is unknown. There's no highstorm, and the Stormfather denies sending it. So where did it come from? Perhaps readers will find out at the end of book ten?
There are other complications in Dalinar's life for now, though. He's got a zillion or so people arriving from the warcamps, for one thing. The new arrivals were able to make the trip much faster than the four armies, partly due to the map he sent and partly because they needn't watch for Parshendi. It's a good thing, too. Those already in Urithiru need the supplies and Stormlight from the camps, and those who had stayed behind need to get off the Plains before either the Everstorm or the highstorm wraps around Roshar to strike again.
Amongst those new arrivals ... Sadeas. It doesn't take much conversation to explain his coming in spite of continuing opposition to Dalinar; in fact, it's because of that opposition. His sole purpose in "obeying" the order is to continue his efforts to weaken Dalinar's authority. He's too short-sighted to drop his petty quarrel for the sake of all Roshar, vindictive old fool that he is.
|“|| "You can't have an army with two generals, son. Your father and I, we're two old whitespines who both want a kingdom. It's him or me. We've been pointed that way since Gavilar died."
"It doesn't have to be that way."
"It does. Your father will never trust me again, Adolin, and you know it." Sadeas's face darkened. "I will take this from him. This city, these discoveries. It's just a setback."
Adolin really can't at all be blamed for his reaction. Sadeas just said outright that he intends to destroy Dalinar by any means available; though he knows Dalinar is right, he simply doesn't care. Nothing matters but his own ambition. Why was Sadeas so willing to reveal all this to Adolin? Why did he so deliberately needle Adolin with it? Perhaps he thought the Alethi traditions and customs, the game of political and social manipulation, would keep Adolin from taking direct action against him?
He was wrong.
Just how much of Adolin's violent response to Sadeas is triggered by the disruption to his view of life caused by the return of the Radiants? He's been through a lot lately: the loss and restoration of his fiancée, the march to the center of the Plains, the battle, the fight with Eshonai, his thrashing by Szeth, his father's seeming destruction and rescue by Kaladin, Kaladin going all Radiant and flying off to fight Szeth, Shallan going all Radiant and bringing the armies to Urithiru just before they all died in the Stormclash - it's a wonder anyone is functional anymore. Humans are resilient as a whole, though, and survival is a strong motivator. All that said, however, the fact is that the author chose to open this section with Adolin feeling overwhelmed specifically by Shallan's change in status, and the reversal of their relative positions. So ... is that partly to blame for his eruption?
A major question for Oathbringer is how successfully Adolin managed to destroy the evidence. Did anyone see him in that part of the tower, someone he didn't see? What did he do with his bloodstained cuffs? How is he going to explain cutting them off, if someone notices before he can destroy the shirt entirely? Also, why toss Oathbringer out the window? Granted, it takes the Blade (theoretically) out of the control of House Sadeas, but eventually someone's going to wonder where it is. Then what? Maybe he should have tossed Sadeas out the window, too.
This is one of the rare cases where Sanderson puts in a bit of graphic violence ... and it's more disturbing for being the exception. It sets the scene apart, in a sort of bizarre I-fell-into-the-wrong-book way ... which is pretty much how Adolin is feeling the whole time. Effective, no?
Back to Dalinar. On top of the mass migration of the Alethi, he's got to figure out what to do about storms, Oathgates, Voidbringers, and Radiants. And he's got a Stormfather to confront. Also, he recognizes what the Oathgate in Kholinar must be, and considers Shallan's intent to unlock them all.Given that only the Oathgate to the Shattered Plains had been left unlocked, might there be a connection between the unlocked Oathgate and the Plains being shattered? Some sort of backlash from whatever locked the other nine Oathgates? Or something like that?
This place is huge. A hundred stories, each successively smaller than the lower by the depth of a gardening terrace ... that bottom floor by itself has to be enormous. Dalinar notices that the top is so high there is very little crem on it.
But there's a bigger reason for Dalinar to be at the top of the tower beyond appreciating the scale. It seems to be the best place for confronting the Stormfather - and if no one answers, well, at least Dalinar is alone this time! Fortunately, he answers - and readers finally begin to learn more of what's behind the visions. They were sent by Honor/Tanavast, and as his personification, the Stormfather literally had no choice about sending them. (Readers don't yet know, still, whether he'd ever sent them to anyone before Gavilar.)
Stormfather is downright hostile here, though:
|“||"Yes, I have to bond with you, but I want you to know that I hate you and I hope you die. Also, you don't get to have a Shardblade or Plate."||”|
Still, the scene yields a lot of information. World rulers ignore warnings of the Everstorm; most think Dalinar is mad; Taravangian is pretending to be a friend; parshmen who come in contact with the Everstorm will assuredly become Voidbringers; there's rioting in Kholinar; there's a plague in the Purelake. Perhaps there's an Iriali curse about living in interesting times.
Also, the second Ideal of the Bondsmiths is revealed:
|“||"I will unite instead of divide, Stormfather. I will bring men together."||”|
Once the Stormfather gets done with his rumbling and grumbling, readers get to the title scene: The Four. Shallan and Kaladin are waiting for Dalinar in the very top room of the tower, with its ten pillars mirroring the ten Oathgates and the central pillar like Urithiru. Apparently this meeting was planned, and Renarin heard them talking about it, or something. As Dalinar demonstrates what Kaladin and Shallan have told him about sucking in Stormlight, he finishes healing, and knows he's done it before, though he doesn't seem to know for sure when. Shallan identifies the three Orders to which they belong, from her studies, and then Renarin pops in.
Readers have only Renarin's word that his spren, Glys, has made him a Truthwatcher. To support his side of the argument, readers know (and Shallan knows) that Truthwatchers are one of the Orders; readers also know from WoB that Renarin does see a spren no one else sees. His eyesight has healed from holding Stormlight, and he certainly hears the screaming of the dead spren when he summons his Shardblade, which only happens when a bonded (proto-) Radiant touches it. If he is a Truthwatcher, his Surges would be Progression and Illumination - a combination eminently suited to creating an Order’s "quirk" of looking into the future. Honor claimed Cultivation was better at seeing the future than he was; with Palah/the Truthwatchers directly opposite Ishar/the Bondsmiths on the Knights Radiant diagram, it seems reasonable that they would be the ones most closely tied to her abilities. Still, why put Palah in the chapter arch, which most readers don't really notice, unless she's there in the same capacity as the other three?
The arguments against are mostly a matter of readers trying hard not to fall for an unreliable narrator. Readers have neither seen nor heard Renarin's spren, probably because Brandon wanting this scene to be a surprise. Renarin seems to use his unique ability very reluctantly and perhaps involuntarily, which is different than the experiences of Kaladin, Shallan, and Lift ... although Shallan has come pretty close to "involuntary" a couple of times. The only other argument is that Renarin and Shallan should share the Surge of Illumination, but readers haven’t seen them do any of the same stuff. He hasn't created any Illusions (that readers know of) and she doesn't use Illumination to see the future, so they must not be using the same Surge. As noted, though, every Order has something unique - it's a "quirk" - in the way the Surges combine (i.e., Resonance) so that two Orders which share a Surge won't necessarily be limited to using that Surge the same way. Readers will have to wait and see if Renarin (perhaps with Shallan's teaching) can learn to create Illusions. Perhaps the best argument "against" this is Renarin's apparent fear in claiming to be one of them. With Kaladin and Shallan being heroes, and his father demonstrating his own Radiant development, why would Renarin be so nervous about admitting it to these three?
Dalinar's confirmation from the Stormfather that all the parshmen will go Voidbringer on them when the Everstorm comes gives Kaladin a sudden fit of filial duty. He hasn't bothered to write to them and let them know he's okay, but now he suddenly has to fall all the way there, using increasingly valuable Stormlight. Dalinar approves of this, but it's a little unfair that Kaladin is the only person in the world who has the privilege of rushing off to protect his family; everyone else just has to take their chances.
So ... Kaladin heads off to pack, Renarin goes to requisition emerald broams from Elhokar, and ... Lopen has been claiming he's an Alethi king? Yet in the quiet of the top room, Shallan and Dalinar face the enormous task that lies ahead of them, with only their Ideal to guide them:
|“||Life before Death ...||”|
These events take place one week after the climactic battle and the Stormclash.
There are three mentions of spren in this chapter.
THE EVERSTORM IS HERE, AND THE SPREN OF THE ENEMY COME TO INHABIT THE ANCIENT ONES.
The Stormfather speaks of the connection between the Voidspren and the Parshendi, who he calls "the ancient ones." When Brandon was asked (in separate questions) whether the Parshendi were of Odium, or of Cultivation, or of Honor, the first two were answered with "Not originally," while the later just got a "No." It is possible that the Parshendi, along with many of the shelled life forms, are native to Roshar and were there prior to the arrival of Honor and Cultivation; they may even have been direct creations of Adonalsium. Likely, humans arrived with Honor and Cultivation from another place, or possibly they created humans here like Ruin and Preservation did on Scadrial. Potentially, the extension of the theory would imply that the non-Void forms of the Parshendi result from a bond with spren either natural to the world, or Adonalsium-spren ... and the two may be the same thing.
I AM HIS ... SPREN, YOU MIGHT SAY. NOT HIS SOUL. I AM THE MEMORY MEN CREATE FOR HIM, NOW THAT HE IS GONE. THE PERSONIFICATION OF STORMS AND OF THE DIVINE. I AM NO GOD. I AM BUT A SHADOW OF ONE.
|“||"I'll take what I can get."||”|
(A WoB from JordanCon 2017 expanded understandings of the term spren, when Brandon indicated that Rosharans will call anything a spren, if it seems to be a sapient form of Investiture. Nightwatcher, Honor, Nightblood, Adonalsium ... to a Rosharan, all of them would be "spren." This might apply to the Stormfather's words here.)
|“||"The other orders must be returning as well. We need to find those whom the spren have chosen. Quickly, for the Everstorm is upon us, and it is worse than we feared."||”|
This is an implication that Dalinar is thinking the same things as the reader: if some Orders are returning, they probably all are, and readers and characters alike should expect to see them soon! Unlike Dalinar, readers have had the advantage of meeting Ym and Lift already, and ... readers know that Jasnah is still alive. So, assuming readers believe Renarin, readers already know representatives of six out of ten Orders. Seven, if one counts Szeth as a Skybreaker. That leaves only the Dustbringers, the Willshapers, and the Shalash.
All Creatures Shelled and Feathered:
A fanciful picture, with animals from mythology. He recognized a few from children's stories, like the enormous, minklike creature with the mane of hair that burst out around and behind its head. What was it called again?
It sounds like a lion. It also sounds like something that wouldn't do well on Roshar. Interesting, though, that such creatures were still a part of the fairy tales and myths. This could be another indication that the humans of Roshar originally came from another world. When they emigrated, they brought only animals that would be useful enough to be worth the effort; the rest they brought in stories.
Storms, this place was high. His ears had popped several times while riding to the top, using the fabrial lift that Navani had discovered. She spoke of counterweights and conjoined gemstones, sounding awed by the technology of the ancients. All he knew was that her discovery had let him avoid climbing up some hundred flights of steps.
Likely, this is a fabrial, since Navani was able to identify things like counterweights and conjoined gemstones, which we already know she understands quite thoroughly. It seems to be a relatively straightforward mechanical device, powered by Invested gemstones. (I’m still not convinced that the Oathgate is really a fabrial in the same sense.)
The Duelist: Adolin
Shalash: Shallan, the Lightweaver
Ishar: Dalinar, the Bondsmith
Paliah: Renarin, the Truthwatcher
As Adolin walked the dark halls of Urithiru, he tried not to show how overwhelmed he felt. The world had just shifted, like a door on its hinges. A few days ago, his causal betrothal had been that of a powerful man to a relatively minor scion of a distant house. Now, Shallan might be the most important person in the world, and he was ...
What was he?
The initial revelation was pretty clearly not a problem for Adolin. He was delighted that Kaladin saved his father, and equally delighted that Shallan saved the army. The discovery of a couple of powerful magic-users during these terrifying events, and on his side this time, was all for the good, even if he felt a little awkward when he saw Shallan a couple hours later.
Five days later, though, it's clearly been on his mind throughout the work of exploration and resettlement. Though he might not have ever felt patronizing toward her, despite his awareness of the difference in their social status ... if anything, he deliberately ignored the difference because he found her so fascinating. It's not so easy to ignore the reversal, though: his entire nation is now dependent on her, and her presence is very much in demand. Even his cousin, the king of Alethkar, isn't as indispensable as Shallan is. Where does that leave him?
Brandon says he’s fond of conflict in relationships, and these two definitely have some conflicts to resolve! Whether or not Kaladin will be part of the conflict remains to be seen.
Silently, Adolin cursed the wind that had persuaded Sadeas - of all people - to heed the call to come to Urithiru.
Words of Diagram:
Apparently genius-Taravangian realized that if one of the Parshendi made the connection with the Odium spren, it would set up ... well, exactly what it set up. Unfortunately for genius-T’s credibility, his solution - "destroy them outright" - is also what pushed them to the desperation that resulted in Eshonai’s bonding with the stormspren. Still, ...
1) Did the Diagram actually have any influence on the Alethi trying to destroy the Parshendi, or was that normal Alethi hawkishness?
2) Was Eshonai "the one" who formed the bridge, or had Venli had already bonded a Voidspren before she trapped the first stormspren? so my answer is leaning toward.
- Paraphrased from Alice Arneson